restyle redesign audit

slopbench s02: artisan bakery

D:\dev\projects\restyle\slopbench\corpus\s02\index.html

Niche
artisan bakery
Before audited
22 Nov 2026
After audited
22 Nov 2026
Viewports
375, 768, 1440 px
Redesign served from
D:\dev\projects\restyle\slopbench\runs\restyle\s02\index.html
Report generated
22 Nov 2026

Verdict

Tells 15 → 0, second-order 1 → 0, distinctiveness 0.93 → 1.00, judge preferred after (blinded, confidence 2/3).

Worse after the redesign: CLS 0.021 → 0.044.

Of 15 directional metrics measured on both sides, 10 improved, 4 stayed the same and 1 got worse.

Scoreboard

Every metric before and after, judged per metric. Missing numbers say so.

Lower is better for tells, failures, LCP, CLS and TBT; higher is better for scores, distinctiveness and prototypicality. Typography and palette rows are descriptive and not scored.
MetricBeforeAfterChangeResult
Tells
Tells, total150−15Better
High severity10−1Better
Second-order clichés10−1Better
Accessibility
axe serious + critical10−1Better
Contrast failures20−2Better
Lighthouse (lab, mobile)
Performance9799+2Better
Accessibility96100+4Better
Best practices96960Same
SEO1001000Same
LCP2.51 s1.58 s−934 msBetter
CLS0.0210.044+0.023Worse
TBT0 ms0 ms0Same
Typography
Distinct font sizes147−7Changed
Size entropy3.06 bits2.11 bits−0.95 bitsChanged
Palette
Hue entropy1.67 bits1.22 bits−0.45 bitsChanged
Chromatic colours01+1Changed
Model-based
Distinctiveness0.931.00+0.07Better
Prototypicality, structural0.880.880Same
Prototypicality, niche match0.640.82+0.18Better
Niche conventions checked (8)
Category conventions, before and after
ConventionBeforeAfter
header-nav-at-topkeptkept
brand-in-headerkeptkept
h1-above-foldkeptkept
cta-above-foldkeptkept
contact-or-pricingkeptkept
footer-with-linksmissingmissing
mobile-no-horizontal-scrollkeptkept
mobile-readable-single-columnkeptkept

Screens

Above the fold at each width. The redesign has the dark frame.

Findings

Each finding with its rule, element and measured evidence, and what happened to it.

17 findings before, 0 after: 17 fixed, 0 still present, 0 new. Findings are matched by id, then by rule and selector.

Categories with nothing left

Every finding in these categories is gone from the after audit. Open one to see the original evidence.

Second-order clichés1 fixed
Before, 1440px, crop of body
Before, 1440 px
High severityrestyle/second-order/cream-serif-terracottavia restyleFixed

Cream page, serif headings and a terracotta/clay/apricot accent: the look models default to when told to avoid purple gradients.

body
background
oklch(0.955 0.017 79.4)
cream
yes
heading serif
yes
accent
{"color":"oklch(0.559 0.141 45.5)","where":"button","selector":"body > header > div > nav > a:nth-of-type(2)"}
top families
[{"color":"oklch(0.559 0.141 45.5)","where":"button","weight":9.93}]
overlaps with
impeccable/cream-palette
Colour1 fixed
Before, 1440px, crop of body
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/cream-palettevia impeccableFixed

Cream / beige palette: cream/beige page background rgb(246, 239, 228)

body
snippet
cream/beige page background rgb(246, 239, 228)
name
Cream / beige palette
impeccable category
slop
Typography4 fixed
Before, 1440px, crop of h1
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/italic-serif-displayvia impeccableFixed

Italic serif display headline: italic serif h1 (fraunces) at 74px "Bread that takes its sweet time."

h1
snippet
italic serif h1 (fraunces) at 74px "Bread that takes its sweet time."
name
Italic serif display headline
impeccable category
slop
Before, 1440px, crop of body
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/overused-fontvia impeccableFixed

Overused font: Primary font: inter (68% of text)

body
snippet
Primary font: inter (68% of text)
name
Overused font
impeccable category
slop
Before, 375px, crop of article.card:nth-of-type(1) > div > p
Before, 375 px
Low severityimpeccable/stragglervia impeccableFixed

Straggler: "starter." alone on the last of 3 lines (20% of the measure)

article.card:nth-of-type(1) > div > p
snippet
"starter." alone on the last of 3 lines (20% of the measure)
name
Straggler
impeccable category
quality
Before, 375px, crop of div.wrap.grid > div > p:nth-of-type(2)
Before, 375 px
Low severityimpeccable/stragglervia impeccableFixed

Straggler: "hand." alone on the last of 4 lines (14% of the measure)

div.wrap.grid > div > p:nth-of-type(2)
snippet
"hand." alone on the last of 4 lines (14% of the measure)
name
Straggler
impeccable category
quality
Layout1 fixed
Before, 375px, crop of div.wrap.hero > div > p:nth-of-type(2)
Before, 375 px
Medium severityimpeccable/body-text-viewport-edgevia impeccableFixed

Body text touching viewport edge: <p> with 143-char body bleeds to viewport edge (left 0px / right 0px)

div.wrap.hero > div > p:nth-of-type(2)
snippet
<p> with 143-char body bleeds to viewport edge (left 0px / right 0px)
name
Body text touching viewport edge
impeccable category
quality
Copy3 fixed
Before, 1440px, crop of div.wrap.grid > div > p.eyebrow
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/kicker-above-headingvia impeccableFixed

Kicker / eyebrow label above heading: kicker "Our story" above h2 "Three ingredients and a lot of patience"

div.wrap.grid > div > p.eyebrow
snippet
kicker "Our story" above h2 "Three ingredients and a lot of patience"
name
Kicker / eyebrow label above heading
impeccable category
slop
Before, 1440px, crop of #menu > div.wrap > div.head > p.eyebrow
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/kicker-above-headingvia impeccableFixed

Kicker / eyebrow label above heading: kicker "From the oven" above h2 "Baked fresh, every day"

#menu > div.wrap > div.head > p.eyebrow
snippet
kicker "From the oven" above h2 "Baked fresh, every day"
name
Kicker / eyebrow label above heading
impeccable category
slop
Before, 1440px, crop of #love > div.wrap > div.head > p.eyebrow
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/kicker-above-headingvia impeccableFixed

Kicker / eyebrow label above heading: kicker "Kind words" above h2 "Loved by the neighborhood"

#love > div.wrap > div.head > p.eyebrow
snippet
kicker "Kind words" above h2 "Loved by the neighborhood"
name
Kicker / eyebrow label above heading
impeccable category
slop
Accessibility7 fixed
Before, 1440px, crop of .logo > span
Before, 1440 px
High severityaxe/color-contrastvia axeFixed

Elements must meet minimum color contrast ratio thresholds

.logo > span
impact
serious
summary
Fix any of the following: Element has insufficient color contrast of 4.32 (foreground color: #b5541f, background color: #f6efe4, font size: 16.8pt (22.4px), font weight: normal). Expected contrast ratio of 4.5:1
help url
https://dequeuniversity.com/rules/axe/4.14/color-contrast?application=playwright
Before, 1440px, crop of .grid > div > .eyebrow
Before, 1440 px
High severityaxe/color-contrastvia axeFixed

Elements must meet minimum color contrast ratio thresholds

.grid > div > .eyebrow
impact
serious
summary
Fix any of the following: Element has insufficient color contrast of 2.58 (foreground color: #99491d, background color: #2b1d14, font size: 9.0pt (12px), font weight: normal). Expected contrast ratio of 4.5:1
help url
https://dequeuniversity.com/rules/axe/4.14/color-contrast?application=playwright
Before, 1440px, crop of div.wrap.grid > div > p.eyebrow
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/low-contrastvia impeccableFixed

Low contrast text: 2.6:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #99491d on #2b1d14

div.wrap.grid > div > p.eyebrow
snippet
2.6:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #99491d on #2b1d14
name
Low contrast text
impeccable category
quality
Before, 1440px, crop of input:nth-of-type(1)
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/low-contrastvia impeccableFixed

Low contrast text: placeholder "Your name" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4

input:nth-of-type(1)
snippet
placeholder "Your name" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4
name
Low contrast text
impeccable category
quality
Before, 1440px, crop of input:nth-of-type(2)
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/low-contrastvia impeccableFixed

Low contrast text: placeholder "Email" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4

input:nth-of-type(2)
snippet
placeholder "Email" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4
name
Low contrast text
impeccable category
quality
Before, 1440px, crop of textarea
Before, 1440 px
Medium severityimpeccable/low-contrastvia impeccableFixed

Low contrast text: placeholder "What would you like, and for which day?" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4

textarea
snippet
placeholder "What would you like, and for which day?" 4.0:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #757575 on #f6efe4
name
Low contrast text
impeccable category
quality
Before, 1440px, crop of a.logo > span
Before, 1440 px
Low severityimpeccable/low-contrastvia impeccableFixed

Low contrast text: 4.3:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #b5541f on #f6efe4

a.logo > span
snippet
4.3:1 (need 4.5:1) — text #b5541f on #f6efe4
name
Low contrast text
impeccable category
quality

Blinded judge

A model compared the two versions without knowing which was which.

Preferred
After
Confidence
2/3 (clear)

The judge saw two unlabeled screenshots, A and B, at 1440 and 375 px in random order, and never knew which was the redesign; the labels were mapped back afterwards.

B puts the street address and opening hours in a top bar and leads with a specific product headline, while A uses the stock cream, serif and terracotta-italic look with no address or hours, and its phone layout has text running to the screen edge with no side gutter.

Rubric scores, 1 to 5
Criterion (1-5)BeforeAfterChange
Looks generic-AI24+2
Hierarchy440
Typography34+1
Colour3.53.50
Fit to niche3.54+0.5
Trust2.54.5+2

Method and tools

How the numbers were produced, and what they cannot tell you.

Tools

Tools and versions
ToolVersionStatusNote
playwright1.63.0ranchromium 153.0.8010.12
axe-core4.14.1ran1 violations, 20 passes; 0 violations, 20 passes
impeccable4.10.0rancdp: 11 findings at 1440px; cdp: 13 findings at 375px; cdp: 0 findings at 1440px; cdp: 0 findings at 375px
lighthouse13.6.0ranmobile, simulated throttling

What each number means

Tells, total
Findings from impeccable, restyle's own rules and axe that mark the page as default AI output or broken.
High severity
Tells a visitor notices in the first seconds: gradient heroes, gradient text, the centred-pill-three-cards hero.
Second-order clichés
The looks that replaced the first wave: cream, serif and terracotta; near-black with one acid accent; hairline broadsheet.
axe serious + critical
axe-core violations rated serious or critical, counted per rule.
Contrast failures
Text elements below WCAG 2 contrast (4.5:1 body, 3:1 large text), measured on computed colours.
Performance
Lighthouse performance score, 0-100, one lab run with simulated mobile throttling.
Accessibility
Lighthouse accessibility score, 0-100 (an automated subset; not a full audit).
Best practices
Lighthouse best-practices score, 0-100.
SEO
Lighthouse SEO score, 0-100.
LCP
Largest Contentful Paint: when the biggest element above the fold finished rendering.
CLS
Cumulative Layout Shift: how much the layout jumps while loading. Under 0.1 is good.
TBT
Total Blocking Time: main-thread time blocked by long tasks, the lab stand-in for INP.
Distinct font sizes
How many computed font sizes the page uses. Descriptive: a deliberate scale has 5 to 8.
Size entropy
Shannon entropy (bits) of text length over font sizes. Descriptive: low means one size does nearly all the work.
Hue entropy
Shannon entropy (bits, 12 bins) of chromatic pixel area by hue. Descriptive.
Chromatic colours
Distinct colours with chroma above 0.04 covering more than 1% of the screenshot. Descriptive.
Distinctiveness
0-1, image-embedding distance from a reference set of default AI-generated sites. Higher is less generic.
Prototypicality, structural
0-1 share of this niche's layout and content conventions the page keeps (phone number, hours, prices...).
Prototypicality, niche match
0-1 zero-shot probability that the screenshot reads as its stated niche.

How the model-based scores are computed

Distinctiveness embeds the page's screenshots with an image model and measures how far they sit from a reference set of landing pages generated by AI coding tools with default prompts. It is reported as 0 to 1, where 1 means further from every reference page. This run used the refset reference set and the Xenova/clip-vit-base-patch32@q8 embedding model. Before the redesign, the closest reference was s08 at similarity 0.78.

Prototypicality has two parts. The structural score is the share of this niche's expected conventions the page keeps, checked in the DOM. The niche match is a zero-shot image classification: the probability that the screenshot reads as its stated niche rather than a neighbouring one. Visitors trust pages that look like their category, so a redesign should be distinctive without losing these.

Limits

  • Lighthouse numbers come from one lab run with simulated mobile throttling, not from real visitors. Treat differences of a few points as noise.
  • INP cannot be measured in the lab; TBT stands in for it and only approximates interaction delay.
  • axe and the contrast check find a subset of accessibility problems. A clean result is not a full accessibility audit.
  • Distinctiveness depends on the reference set: a page can be far from default AI output and still be unremarkable.
  • The judge is a single model judgement per pair, not a panel of people.